As Bill Lawry Would Say: ‘It’s All Happening’

Ashton Agar after getting out for 98 in the First Test

So for once, instead of struggling to come up with a topic to write about, this week there has been so much going on that I couldn’t decide which topic to pick. Therefore, as the fence sitter than I am, I figured I’ll just touch on a bit of everything and then reward myself with a weekend away.

To start, let’s talk about the Origin decider. The Queensland streak remains alive after they hung on to win by two and NSW have to wait another year to try to end the drought. Those who follow me on Twitter or Facebook know that I, like many others, think the biggest issue for NSW was halfback Mitchell Pearce.

The only people I have seen defending Pearce have been Roosters fans and even Roosters fans have been divided on it. I am not questioning Pearce’s heart or effort levels. I think he desperately wants to be the best player he can and gave it his all yet again, but he quite simply isn’t good enough. He is a good defender for his position but NSW need a halfback that can create points and that is something Pearce has not done in five years playing for NSW.

His kicking game is below par and he doesn’t have the dynamic passing or running game. He also didn’t take control of the direction of the team, which lead to many plays that looked like they had no plan.

The argument that a halfback needs a forward pack going forward to be able to perform doesn’t hold water here either as the NSW pack won the arm wrestle. NSW had every opportunity to win game 3 as well as getting the better of the forward back for the last two years in general. Pearce may well be a great guy, but he has had more than enough chances and it’s time NSW make the move they should have made before this series. It’s certainly a popular opinion and I’m not saying anything that hasn’t been said elsewhere over and over, but enough is enough and it’s time the Pearce experiment ends. He just isn’t that good.

Onto the Ashes, where Australia lost the First Test but there were certainly a number of positives to take out of it. From a neutral standpoint it was one of the most entertaining and gripping Tests I have ever watched and whilst Australia ended up on the losing end, it gave me belief that we can absolutely make this a competitive series.

Darren Lehmann’s decision to play Ashton Agar instantly paid off with one of the greatest moments in Test history, with a 19 year old Agar, batting 11 and with Australia in dire straits, getting to 98 (alongside a tremendous knock by Phil Hughes) before holing out trying to get his century.

There is clearly a concern with the top order, which hopefully will be rectified as the series moves forward, but I can’t remember a tail that so consistently wags. Our bowlers are honestly not that much worse at batting than our specialist batsmen are. Which isn’t really a compliment to our batsmen, but is still praise for our bowlers.

As I write this the team for the Second Test was announced and so I had to quickly rewrite this bit about selections for the match. Cowan was axed as expected and replaced by Usman Khawaja, who was the likely replacement. Mitchell Starc also makes way with Ryan Harris getting the nod over Jackson Bird as the replacement fast bowler. Cowan had to go and Starc has been a bit down on form so neither was unexpected. I wasn’t sure whether Harris, Bird or a second spinner would come in depending on the conditions and it’s hard to argue with Ryan Harris getting the nod.

But either way, I’m no longer feeling as down about our chances for the series as I was before the First Test, which is saying something considering we are now officially trailing in the series.

Also a quick point on the whole DRS and Stuart Broad saga. First of all, I think we need to be a bit careful to put all the blame on England, when we got a bit lucky ourselves in the first innings with Agar and the fact that Clarke continues to misuse the review system. That said, Broad should have walked and the fact that he didn’t absolutely makes him a dirty cheat.  Also, the on field umpires were atrocious for both sides and this wouldn’t be an issue if they actually did their job at a level even near competent. Aleem Dar is one of the worst umpires I can remember and it baffles me how he continues to get such big matches. He is like cricket’s Jason Robinson.

Onto Le Tour. Whilst some of the individual stages have been exciting, is it just me or is the fact that Chris Froome is so dominant making the race kind of boring. It’s hard to stay up at night knowing the result is already over barring injury. That’s not to take anything away from Froome himself. He was expected to do this and he is delivering in spades and proving that he probably would have won Le Tour last year as well if his team had let him.

I also think raising speculation of him cheating as the media have been doing is ridiculous. It’s an unfortunately side effect of the sport’s history, but Froome has done nothing to suggest he is cheating besides being really, really good. I’d like to think he isn’t cheating because neither are his competitors anymore. However, should he end up in a doping scandal at any stage, it would be tragic and would be another nail into the coffin of the sport for many people.

We also are currently being graced with the presence of English Premier League champions Manchester United, who are here to play an A-League All Stars team this weekend. Then next Wednesday, my beloved Liverpool will be taking on the Melbourne Victory and I am fortunate enough to be traveling to Melbourne to watch the game. I’ve never seen Liverpool play and I’ve never been to a sporting event at the MCG, so to say I’m excited would be an understatement.

I hope to write about the experience next week, so stay tuned for that and remember, ‘You’ll Never Walk Alone’.

Turning Blue

Greg Bird applauds the fans after Game 1

So Origin 1 is behind us and finally NSW will play the series from in front. It was a fascinating game, which had incidents, some brilliance and a potential sign of a change of fortunes.

Overall New South Wales were fantastic and it was exactly the sort of win they needed to allow them to play with confidence for the rest of the series to try and end the Queensland streak. Going into the game, most people seemed to believe that NSW held the edge in the forward pack whilst Queensland had a more dangerous backline and of course held the edge in the all-important spine of 1, 6, 7 and 9.

New South Wales built their foundation on that forward pack and overall they destroyed the Maroon’s forwards, forcing Thurston and Cronk to play on the back foot for most of the game. Guys like Gallen, Watmough and Greg Bird are built to play Origin and didn’t disappoint.

However the standout was clearly Luke Lewis, who had one of the great individual Origin performances. No he didn’t score a try or have that many highlight plays, but his hit ups, tackles and passes were extraordinary and he never stopped. He rightfully won the Man of the Match award and it was well deserved for a player who often doesn’t get the plaudits of some of his more flashy or exciting colleagues.

On the other hand, I thought Mitchell Pearce had a very mediocre game for a victorious NSW side. Before I get accused of Rooster hating, I thought James Maloney was superb on debut and Michael Jennings was brilliant too. Pearce however, was non-existent. The guy is playing halfback, which if you don’t know, is supposed to be a pretty important position in a football team and yet he seemed to barely touch the ball. When he did he mostly just dropped it off for a forward to take a hit up and my only memory of him throwing a longer ball was when he underthrew a pass to Lewis, which Lewis unfortunately couldn’t reel in.

Pearce is a solid defender and he wasn’t poor there, but he certainly was no halfback either. In such a great team performance his individual effort won’t cop much criticism and I know he won’t be dropped, but it still should be pointed out that we won in spite of him and not because of him. Oh, I also thought Ryan Hoffman had a surprisingly poor game with some bad drops and not much impact.

The standouts for NSW in my eyes were the aforementioned Lewis, the always awesome at Origin level despite his club form Jarryd Hayne, Maloney on debut, the ever reliable Robbie Farah and the “Bash Brothers” Bird and Gallen.

This brings me to the Paul Gallen punching Nate Myles incident. Yes, I understand that Origin has a different atmosphere and level of leniency, but in my eyes Gallen was very lucky to stay on the field. It doesn’t matter if Nate Myles is a dirty player or if he plays for Queensland, Gallen put a deliberate high shot on him and then when Myles got up unhappy about it, Gallen rocked him with two punches.

Would Myles have punched Gal if Gal didn’t do it first? Maybe. But that incident was all Gallen and regardless of what game it happened in, in my eyes it is not on. Had a Queenslander done it to a Blue, all of NSW would be crying foul and especially if it happened to a player from the individual club you support. So the idea of “that’s Origin” is bullshit in my eyes. Rugby league is a contact sport but it is not a combat sport, even at Origin. That wasn’t a fight; it was one player deciding to punch another.

So those fans who genuinely think it was awesome, or if you think it’s great because it happened to Nate Myles, I think you watch football for the wrong reasons and need to reconsider your values. I like a bit of Origin biffo as much as the next guy, but last night was not that. Anyway, NSW got a lucky break, but Queensland have had numerous breaks over the last few years so it was bound to even out and I don’t feel too bad.

Meanwhile, what about on the Maroon side of things? They finally looked old after a near decade of dominating the Origin arena. Their forwards were dominated, Thurston was completely out of sorts and even the Storm ‘Big Three’ struggled to impact the game.

Greg Inglis barely touched the ball and the one time he finally got decent possession he created Queensland’s only try. I doubt they will do it, but I think they need to switch Inglis and Slater in Game 2, at least at various points during the game to get Inglis involved. He is simply too important and valuable to them to not utilise more. Plus he is one of the few Queensland playmakers that can create without the forwards getting momentum first.

As a biased Souths and NSW fan however, I hope he stays at centre, barely touches the ball and simply gets through the game unscathed.

Another takeaway from the game last night is that we have all still played as much State of Origin as Josh Reynolds. I like Josh Reynolds and think he will play plenty of Origin in his career. It is not his fault he didn’t play, nor is it his fault he was selected at all. But this idea of selection a utility player for purely backup reasons and not even using him is insane to me. Origin is the hardest, fastest, most tiring form of footy and NSW are giving up one of their bench spots as a ‘break glass in case of injury’ backup plan.

It is no coincidence that as NSW forwards got tired in the second half; Queensland scored their try and came close to scoring more. Yes we won anyway, but it damn sure would have been a lot more comfortable if we had another player with fresh legs out there. I don’t care if it’s a prop like Tim Grant or a bigger utility that can cover halves like John Sutton, but all 17 positions should be utilised.

A win should never cloud over things that weren’t good just because the overall result was.

Finally, it is being reported that Robbie Farah may have a broken eye socket and is in doubt for Origin 2. That is a nightmare for NSW as Farah is probably the hardest player to replace in the entire team. Go on, name his direct replacement if he can’t play, I’ll wait….

…

Exactly.

Who are our options at 9 without Farah?

Michael Ennis? He’s a mediocre footballer and failed at Origin level already

Josh Reynolds? A good player and would have replaced Farah if Farah came off in Game 1, but he isn’t a hooker.

Mitch Rein and Nathan Peats? Like them both as youngsters but nowhere near Origin level right now and I don’t think either would argue that.

Ryan Hinchcliffe? To be honest I feel like I’d pick Hinchy out of these names even though he is mostly playing lock, but I wouldn’t be happy about it. At least I trust him as a player and feel like he’d handle the Origin cauldron, but the gap from Farah down to the other options is troubling to say the least.

If I’m forgetting anyone please let me know.

Anyway, NSW got a fantastic result in Game 1 and look like a great chance to finally reclaim the Origin crown. I’ll just spend the next three weeks praying to the great cockroach in the sky that Robbie Farah is back in time for the next instalment.

SOO Game 3: So Close But Yet So Far

NSW dejection

Origin has come and gone for another year and yet again we have to endure a year without the shield or interstate bragging rights. Whilst we couldn’t get mathematically closer to winning, without actually winning, at the end of the day QLD were the ones left celebrating.

I could spend all day talking about the video refs and decisions that went against NSW in games 1 and 3 but they were there for all to see and NSW had opportunities to win anyway.

So where to now for the Blues?

Firstly I think Ricky Stuart has done a terrible job this year with the NSW team and whilst I don’t think his job will be in jeopardy, in my opinion it absolutely should be. There were some terrible team selections throughout the series which left NSW behind the 8-ball. The fixation on picking Dragons players, who even my friends who support the Dragons admit aren’t in great form and didn’t deserve to be there this year. Ben Creagh has never been great at Origin level and this season his NRL form has done nothing to deserve a shot in sky blue. Trent Merrin is decent but was coming off the bench for his club side and whilst he may have an Origin future, he wasn’t warranting selection. They eventually figured this out and left him out of the Game 3 side.

Beau Scott somehow got a call-up to replace Glenn Stewart in Game 3 and once again I’m baffled by it. A solid defender who offers little in attack, Scott too has not performed well enough this year to warrant selection in the position NSW is deepest in. Not to mention that if Tariq Sims had been rightfully picked in Game 1, he never would have been playing for the Cowboys to suffer his season ending injury. Plus, poor Aaron Woods deserved to play at least one game this series and instead we just kept getting more underperforming Dragons.

As much as I love Nathan Merritt and want him to play Origin, I had no issue with Brett Morris replacing Uate and he didn’t disappoint. Both Morris twins are classy players and were possibly NSW’s best in Game 3. If only ‘Slippery’ kept breeding and created a few more for us.

Then of course we come to the inclusion of Jamie Buhrer in Game 1. Whilst I understand NSW wanted someone in the utility role and with Gidley unavailable our options were limited. But Luke Lewis and Greg Bird were already in the team and both can cover most positions on the field. Then to only play him for 7 minutes and basically play a man short, that’s just poor decision making and bad coaching.

We also have the major issue that during the games themselves NSW seemed to lack direction or any semblance of a coherent game plan. I put this both down to a lack of coaching, preparation, as well as the fact our halves are so many levels below Queensland’s. Meninga may not be much of a tactician as a coach, but he and Hagan clearly have a game plan in place that his team know how to execute. NSW on the other hand look like they just met each other.

Mitchell Pearce was horrendous in Game 3 and not much better in Games 1 and 2. Todd Carney was horrendous in Game 1 and not much better in Games 2 and 3. Hopefully we aren’t too far away from seeing the likes of Adam Reynolds, Josh Reynolds and some of the next generation putting their hands up to get a shot at the NSW halves positions. We have the Stewart brothers, the Morris brothers... now let’s add the Reynolds “brothers” to the mix.

I really wish Phil Gould would find a way to settle his differences with the NSWRL and come back to save us. He is certainly the best candidate to put an end to the Queensland domination. However if he still refuses to work with the NSWRL, then I’d love for Peter Sterling to have a crack at the job. Everyone seems to be in agreement that he is one of the smartest football brains around and the only thing preventing him from getting a coaching job is his lack of interest.

But for three games a year I wonder if Sterlo could be talked into it.

Please Sterlo.

PS: Brent Tate is a cat.

State of UGHigin

So I’ve now had a night to sleep on the events on last night in State of Origin and obviously as a New South Welshmen (or given the blog title I should say Jew South Welshman) I am both disappointed and angry.

When I analyse sporting results and performances I do always try to take off my fan hat and look at it objectively though. With that being said, even objectively I think NSW got screwed.

For starters, people are arguing over whether Robbie Farah played at the ball when he kicked it out of Inglis’ hands, but frankly it shouldn’t matter if it was deliberate or not for one reason. That reason is that Inglis knocks on again after Farah dislodges the ball. Thus, either way it is no try.

Now Queenslanders will rightly point out that even without that try NSW were down two. This is correct however it neglects the two other huge calls that went against NSW in the game.

The Greg Bird penalty for the dangerous tackle was rubbish, it lead directly to a try and everyone seems to be in agreement on that so I don’t need to go further.

The Jennings sinbinning itself is fine. Bloke ran in and threw a punch. If they are saying you can no longer do that, even in Origin, then fine. Problem is, he was one of many guys who ran in and threw a punch in that fracas and if you are sending Jennings, you have to send the guy who was throwing punches at him too. Thus it would be 12 on 12 and QLD never would have had the overlap that lead to their first try.

However this sinbinning incident made me think about an idea I’ve had for footy for years. People often talk about how they wish there was a third option besides a send off and a 10 minute sinbinning. The idea of a five minute sinbinning has been suggested but I think I have a better idea.

Why can’t footy take a great idea from ice hockey and give out a 10 minute sinbinning, but as soon (or if) the opposition scores a try, the sinbinned player gets to return for the kickoff.

That way the opposition does get a clear advantage to assist them in making the sinbinning offence show on the scoreboard, but not so much that they get said advantage for an 8^th of the match.

Surely this idea has merit. Unfortunately NSW didn’t have Nathan Merritt.

In the interests of not being too much of a sore loser I have added this section about the fact that NSW shot themselves in the foot plenty too. Carney was not only poor in his Origin debut, but actually looked scared. Gotta stick with him for Game 2 but he needs to step it up. NSW had several opportunities in attack and wasted them, including Glenn Stewart pushing a pass on the third tackle, constantly kicking to Tate rather than Boyd, dropping the ball and other poor decisions and plays.

The refs were terrible and a big factor in the result, but NSW could have won the game nonetheless and didn't.